babble-intro-img
babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.

The Game in Canada, beaten, branded, bought and sold

Pondering
Offline
Joined: Jun 14 2013

TBC


Comments

Pondering
Offline
Joined: Jun 14 2013

http://projects.thestar.com/human-sex-trafficking-ontario-canada/

The cops, pimps and victims all call it "The Game." It's no game. Young Canadian girls are being beaten, branded, bought and sold in hotels and motels, and along highways across the GTA and Ontario...

Detectives say the crime is growing because trafficking is so lucrative — a pimp can earn $280,000 a year from one sex-trade worker, according to the RCMP. The Internet has also changed The Game by taking these girls off the streets and hiding them behind closed doors. The girls are typically sold on the website Backpage.com which police say is notorious for running sex trafficking advertisements across North America....

Their stories have similar traits — what lured the girls into The Game was the illusion of love and a secure future.

What made them stay was the fear of being beaten, burnt, “outed as whores” or left for dead, and sometimes threats to their families.

Some of these girls are runaways, abandoned by their parents, or foster kids lured straight out of group homes; others grew up in middle-income households and are recruited from high schools or house parties.

The six victims the Star interviewed said those buying sex were from all walks of life, including businessmen, doctors, lawyers, police officers, labourers, drug dealers, college students, teachers, judges, accountants and soldiers. Occasionally they were women.....

 

Backpage.com: The traffickers' domain

Of the 359 sex trafficking cases Toronto police have investigated since 2013, every single girl was advertised on Backpage.com

 


Pondering
Offline
Joined: Jun 14 2013

A thread was started recently that references this article without mentioning that Canada's law has already fully decriminalized sex workers with the exception of doing business near schools and daycares. It's a silly exception but not terribly limiting.

http://mic.com/articles/142879/4-feminist-reasons-why-we-need-to-support...

 

 


quizzical
Offline
Joined: Dec 8 2011

i call bs on the 4 reasons across the board.


lagatta
Offline
Joined: Apr 17 2002

Yes, but the problem is that feminists who think the commercial sex trade is far from liberating are not allowed to intervene at that forum.

I do support a "safe place" forum for sex workers at babble, but find it unfortunate that it is being used as an echo chamber where people who think the "game" is the antithesis of sexual liberation cannot speak and are maligned.


Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001
Nothing that hasn't already been addressed anyway.

Left Turn
Offline
Joined: Mar 28 2005

lagatta wrote:

Yes, but the problem is that feminists who think the commercial sex trade is far from liberating are not allowed to intervene at that forum.

I do support a "safe place" forum for sex workers at babble, but find it unfortunate that it is being used as an echo chamber where people who think the "game" is the antithesis of sexual liberation cannot speak and are maligned.

It's unfortunate that the proponents and opponents of sex work cannot respectfully disagree on babble, so we could have these discussions in a single place.

It would also allow folks who are neither supporters of the decrim model of sex work, or opponents of sex work, to intervene without pressure to self-censor themselves.


Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001

Some of us do try to respectfully disagree and argue on the merits.  However, that's been neither welcome nor encouraged - capitulation of position is the only acceptable stance in the SW threads. 

I hope you don't self-censor.  I'll disagree with you, potentially, and will probably argue with you, but will do so without malice. 


Pondering
Offline
Joined: Jun 14 2013

Left Turn wrote:

lagatta wrote:

Yes, but the problem is that feminists who think the commercial sex trade is far from liberating are not allowed to intervene at that forum.

I do support a "safe place" forum for sex workers at babble, but find it unfortunate that it is being used as an echo chamber where people who think the "game" is the antithesis of sexual liberation cannot speak and are maligned.

It's unfortunate that the proponents and opponents of sex work cannot respectfully disagree on babble, so we could have these discussions in a single place.

It would also allow folks who are neither supporters of the decrim model of sex work, or opponents of sex work, to intervene without pressure to self-censor themselves.

In the feminist forum we can. It's in the "Sex Worker" forum that we can't because it is a "safe space" for sex workers.

Back to the topic of the lastest article:

http://mic.com/articles/142879/4-feminist-reasons-why-we-need-to-support...

1. Making sex work a crime further marginalizes women, women of color and transgender women. The New York Times reported that women make up more than two-thirds of the people arrested for prostitution every year, or more than approximately 36,667 women nationwide. According to a study by the Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice, women of color in San Francisco are also 31 times more likely to be arrested for prostitution than white women. These laws place a disproportionate burden on women of color and LGBTQ people, who are often racially profiled, arrested and even attacked or killed with impunity.

I hope the US adopts the Canadian approach as in Canada "sex workers" aren't arrested for prostitution unless they are near a school or daycare which I think is likely very rare anyway. I see no reason why a sex worker would choose to hang out near a daycare.

2. Criminalizing sex work promotes a culture of victim-blaming and slut-shaming. 

According to a 2014 study, sex workers have a 45% to 75% likelihood of experiencing sexual assault at some point during their careers. Yet even though sex workers are at an increased risk of being assaulted, their reports are frequently minimized or dismissed by law enforcement, simply by virtue of their professions.

It isn't criminalization that promotes victim-blaming or slut-shaming it is the nature of prostitution that does that. As people begin to see that sex workers are victims not criminals that attitude changes. Of course some sex workers see themselves as professionals not victims but under Canadian law the professionals have the right to hire receptionists, cleaners and guards if they so choose.

3. When selling sex is a crime, sex workers are especially vulnerable to police brutality. Contrary to popular myths about abusive pimps and johns, many sex workers are more scared of law enforcement than they are of their clients. A 2015 data analysis by Vocativ of National Blacklist, a "bad client database and escort safety tool," found that sex workers were posting more online warnings about law enforcement officers than they were about abusive clients.

Fortunately sex workers in Canada need not fear arrest (unless they are near a daycare/school) so can call police without fear. They don't even have to prove anything as the john is automatically breaking the law.

4. Respecting an adult woman's right to make choices about her own body, including consenting to sex work, strikes at the heart of emancipation.  

Many anti-prostitution activists argue that most women who sell sex are doing so against their will, thus conflating victims of sex trafficking with those who sell sex of their own volition. Yet there is a clear distinction between sex work and sex trafficking. 

There is some confusion in the above. Making choices about one's body means you can have sex with anyone you please as long as everyone is a consenting adult. That is at the heart of emancipation.  It doesn't mean you are free to sell any service or product you please.

 


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Login or register to post comments